Study summary · 2026 · Observational
CCM and transitional-care billing: adoption and substitution
New care-management codes were adopted unevenly and correlated with other billing; the study does not establish clinical benefit.
Summary by Vironix Health · Source review: November 11, 2026
How we select and interpret evidence
Original publication
Plugging gaps in payment systems: Evidence from the take-up of new Medicare billing codes
Jeffrey Clemens; Jonathan M. Leganza; Alex Masucci
University of California San Diego; Clemson University; independent researcher, United States
Contemporary Economic Policy · Online: · Issue: January 2026
Journal version of record. · Full text consulted.
What was studied
- Design
- Observational
- Population
- Medicare-billing physicians and counties
- Sample
- 176,676 primary care physicians in the 2018 adoption table; longitudinal analyses use physician-year and county-year observations
- Intervention
- Introduction and uptake of CCM and transitional care management billing codes
- Comparator
- Higher versus lower code uptake over time
- Follow-up
- Annual billing panels, 2012–2018
- Study/data period
- 2012–2018
- Setting
- United States
Methods
Descriptive adoption analysis, fixed-effects regressions and event studies at physician and county levels.
Findings
In 2018, 4.5% of primary care physicians billed CCM and 12.3% billed transitional care management. Higher uptake correlated with more annual wellness billing; transitional-care billing correlated with fewer traditional post-discharge office visits.
Limitations
Billing may reflect recoding as well as added care. Adoption is not randomly assigned. Historical claims and aggregate relationships cannot identify patient health effects or net savings.
What this means for care delivery
Use this evidence to understand implementation and payment behavior. Do not equate more claims with improved outcomes or count substituted services as entirely new care.