Study summary · 2017 · Report
CMS's early national CCM evaluation
CCM was associated with slower spending growth, but results were sensitive to analysis choices.
Summary by Vironix Health · Source review: November 11, 2026
How we select and interpret evidence
Original publication
Evaluation of the Diffusion and Impact of the Chronic Care Management (CCM) Services: Final Report
John Schurrer; Ann O'Malley; Claire Wilson; Nancy McCall; Neetu Jain
Mathematica Policy Research; Claire Wilson, Insight Policy Research. Prepared for the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.
Mathematica Policy Research report for CMS · Online:
Final government-contracted report dated November 2, 2017. · Full text consulted.
What was studied
- Design
- Report
- Population
- Medicare fee-for-service beneficiaries receiving early CCM services.
- Sample
- 12-month analysis: 273,225 CCM beneficiaries and 202,679 comparison beneficiaries.
- Intervention
- CCM services introduced under the 2015 payment policy.
- Comparator
- Matched beneficiaries without CCM.
- Follow-up
- 6, 12 and 18 months; 2014–2016 claims.
- Setting
- United States
Methods
Matched difference-in-differences analysis accompanied a national implementation evaluation.
Findings
At 12 months, estimated Medicare spending growth was $28 lower per beneficiary-month before CCM fees. The report separately estimated $88 million gross savings minus $52 million in paid fees, or $36 million net. The six-month spending result was not significant at 5%.
Limitations
Spending-growth reductions disappeared in survivor-only analyses and when expenditures were not top-coded. Nonrandom enrollment, end-of-life differences and early-adopter settings limit robustness and generalizability. Aggregate net savings are a model estimate, not a guaranteed per-patient return.
What this means for care delivery
Retain this government report as a historical anchor, not a current ROI guarantee.