Study summary · 2024 · Evidence review
Telehealth versus in-person care during the pandemic
Results varied across conditions and outcomes; weak study designs prevent a blanket equivalence claim.
Summary by Vironix Health · Source review: November 11, 2026
How we select and interpret evidence
Original publication
Effectiveness of telehealth versus in-person care during the COVID-19 pandemic: a systematic review
Elham Hatef; Renee F Wilson; Allen Zhang; Susan M Hannum; Hadi Kharrazi; Stacey A Davis; Iman Foroughmand; Jonathan P Weiner; Karen A Robinson
Johns Hopkins School of Medicine and Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, United States
npj Digital Medicine · Online: · Issue: 2024
Journal version of record reporting a subset of a broader AHRQ review; not an independent replication of that report. · Full text consulted.
What was studied
- Design
- Evidence review
- Population
- Patients of all ages receiving outpatient or emergency-department care during COVID-19
- Sample
- 77 studies: 74 observational studies and 3 randomized trials
- Intervention
- Synchronous telephone or video encounters
- Comparator
- In-person care during or before the pandemic
- Follow-up
- Varied by study
- Review search cutoff
- 2023-04
- Setting
- United States and comparable high-income OECD settings
Methods
Four-database review with dual screening, risk-of-bias assessment and outcome-specific evidence grading; descriptive synthesis across 12 outcomes and 7 clinical areas.
Findings
Clinical and utilization differences were often small. Missed visits and adherence often favored telehealth, while laboratory follow-through could be worse. No eligible study addressed 39/84 outcome-by-clinical-area comparisons.
Limitations
47/77 studies had serious or high bias risk; only 26 adjusted for patient characteristics. Historical comparators in 43% confound modality with pandemic changes. Outcomes were inconsistent, and asynchronous monitoring was excluded.
What this means for care delivery
Assess the relevant condition and workflow rather than treating this pandemic evidence as proof of equivalence or as evidence for physiologic RPM.