Study summary · 2025 · Evidence review

Choosing telephone or video consultations

Video often performed as well as or better than telephone, but findings varied by clinical task and outcome.

Summary by Vironix Health · Source review: November 11, 2026
How we select and interpret evidence

Original publication

Telephone versus video consultations: A systematic review of comparative effectiveness studies and guidance for choosing the most appropriate modality

Liam J Caffery; Soraia De Camargo Catapan; Monica L Taylor; Jaimon T Kelly; Helen M Haydon; Anthony C Smith; Centaine L Snoswell

University of Queensland and Princess Alexandra Hospital, Australia; University of Southern Denmark, Denmark

Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare · Online: · Issue: August 2025

Journal version of record; online February 29, 2024; August 2025 issue, volume 31(7), pages 909–918. · Full text consulted.

What was studied

Design
Evidence review
Population
Patients across 23 clinical specialties and multiple settings
Sample
79 articles; 606,592 telephone and 463,259 video patients reported across studies
Intervention
Synchronous video consultation
Comparator
Synchronous telephone consultation
Follow-up
Varied by study
Review search cutoff
2023-04
Setting
Multiple countries; 50/79 articles from the United States

Methods

Descriptive synthesis of comparative empirical studies; no meta-analysis. SQUIRE assessed reporting completeness, alongside an evidence-design hierarchy.

Findings

Authors classified 40/79 studies as favoring video and 3/79 as favoring telephone overall. Service outcomes were mixed. Only 5 studies examined economics. Reported video advantages included visual assessment and some engagement outcomes; no pooled effect size or confidence interval was estimated.

Limitations

Heterogeneity leaves particular findings dependent on small subsets. Reporting quality is not equivalent to low bias risk. The abstract and Results disagree on the number classified as equivalent; that count is omitted here.

What this means for care delivery

Use task-specific evidence when selecting modality; the review cannot establish universal video superiority, savings or patient preference.