Study summary · 2025 · Evidence review
Virtual care for type 2 diabetes: an umbrella review
Virtual diabetes care generally improved HbA1c, but overlapping reviews and mixed interventions limit attribution.
Summary by Vironix Health · Source review: November 11, 2026
How we select and interpret evidence
Original publication
Sumathy Ravi; Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz; Cassia Yung; Julie Ayre; Kirsten McCaffery; Glen Maberly; Carissa Bonner
Western Sydney Diabetes; University of Sydney Sydney Health Literacy Lab and Menzies Centre; University of Wollongong.
BMC Health Services Research · Online: · Issue: March 6, 2025
Final open-access journal article. · Full text consulted.
What was studied
- Design
- Evidence review
- Population
- Adults with type 2 diabetes in existing systematic reviews.
- Sample
- 30 systematic reviews; 16 contributed to HbA1c pooling.
- Intervention
- Mixed virtual-care interventions, including telephone, web and video components.
- Comparator
- Usual care.
- Follow-up
- Varied across the underlying studies and reviews.
- Review search cutoff
- 2022-03
- Setting
- Multiple countries
Methods
Umbrella review with quality appraisal and meta-analysis of review-level estimates.
Findings
Pooling 16 reviews estimated HbA1c 0.37 percentage points lower than usual care (95% CI 0.32–0.41 lower; I²=77.1%). Overlapping primary studies were not statistically removed, so this interval should not be treated as an independent-trial estimate.
Limitations
At least 404 of 847 primary-study entries were duplicates. Dependence may overstate precision. Mixed interventions prevent isolating video or device effects, and the search ended in 2022 despite 2025 publication.
What this means for care delivery
Do not count overlapping reviews as independent trials or interpret the estimate as a device-only RPM effect.